> An application called "External" is built with JSF technology. Our module ,
> let it be "internal". Both External and Internal are within the same EAR
> file.External module talks with Internal through an interface servlet.
> Interface Servlet receives the request from External module, and adds a URL
> parameter ( like http://localhost:8080/Controller?id=200&value=300) and
How do you add the parameter?
> does a RequestDispatcher.forward.
...
> Now the million dollar question, the internal module takes
> request.getParameter("id") and this gives me a NULL!!!! When I print
Are you sure it doesn't give you a null?
> request.getParameterMap, I get so many parameters which were set by External
> in the request. Note that External does a "POST" to interface servlet, which
> in turn again does a "forward" to controller.
Perhaps the URL was added as an attribute, not a parameter?
> One small doubt I am getting - Is JSF ServletRequest different from
> HttpServletRequest ? Then the method of the controller (doGet/doPost) could
> not have been called right? Or a new instance is getting created? Then how I
> am getting query string... ahhhh
A request is a request is a request.
The JSF Faces Servlet grabs it first. The Sun Java EE tutorial goes into
great detail about the JSF life cycle, plus there are many articles out there
about it.
SSCCE, please.
<http://www.physci.org/codes/sscce.html>
(P.S., Andrew, that page has some "<%@" litter peeking through.)

Signature
Lew
Ravion - 20 Nov 2007 20:16 GMT
Hi Lew,
I am not adding a parameter, because we cannot add a parameter to request
manually. I read the string directly from a configuration file, somehwta
like Struts.
The internal module "does" gove me null, when I get parameter.
When I check request.getAttribute("id") or request.getParameter("id") -
both are null.
One more info, if I do the same thing without being sent from a JSF
application, instead from a test JSP, it works, and it works exactly as
expected.
Please help, thanks.
(Regarding multipost, I am extremely sorry, let me continue this)
Thanks an dregards,
Ravion
>> An application called "External" is built with JSF technology. Our module
>> , let it be "internal". Both External and Internal are within the same
[quoted text clipped - 33 lines]
>
> (P.S., Andrew, that page has some "<%@" litter peeking through.)
Andrew Thompson - 20 Nov 2007 23:18 GMT
...
>SSCCE, please.
><http://www.physci.org/codes/sscce.html>
>
>(P.S., Andrew, that page has some "<%@" litter peeking through.)
Thanks Lew - I'll look into it when I get a moment.

Signature
Andrew Thompson
http://www.physci.org/
Ravion - 21 Nov 2007 12:53 GMT
Dear all,
I found the reason finally.
The external module was passing "MulipartRequest", a wrapper class which
wraps HttpServletRequest. And when a multipartrequest is received in a
servlet, request.getParameter will be null. Very useful learning, which
about 100 people could not find...
Thanks and regards,
Ravion
> ..
>>SSCCE, please.
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>
> Thanks Lew - I'll look into it when I get a moment.